jeannette_ng's ‘Mulan’ Has a Message: Serve China and Forget About the Uighurs and Beyond Authenticity: the Spectre of Han Hegemony captured some of the thoughts that I've been trying to articulate about Han ethnocentrism and harmful tropes about the non-Han Other, for lack of better terms.
KatjeXia's Twitter thread provided some specific examples that they've seen in wuxia on this topic.
freeuyghurnow’s Everything Wrong with Disney Mulan summarized the current sociopolitical contexts in which Disney's 2020 live-action Mulan is released. (Transcript of the infographic is available here.)
diversireads's We Don't Need Your Hero & We Don't Need You to Mediate Our Relationship with Her: Four Chinese and Chinese American Adapations of the Ballad of Hua Mulan (which I believe was published in 2017 in response to Disney's live-adaption Mulan news) has some great reviews of Hua Mulan adaptions and additional historical notes about Hua Mulan (at the end of the post).
But Han ethnocentrism is something that I've been thinking more about recently after watching the Detective Dee film trilogy and when reading priest's webnovels, Sha Po Lang, Guardian and Lord Seventh. Like these works may have great wordbuilding and storytelling, but I also think they are pretty flawed and harmful in how they Othered non-Han characters and cultures. And when I continued to see trends in a series or body of work, it affects my enjoyment of the works, especially when I considered current and past sociopolitical contexts of Han Chinese colonialism and imperialism.
And sometimes the Othering may seem innocuous at first but may be equally harmful like as seen in my still much beloved series Nirvana in Fire as
coffeeandink noted in her post about Nirvana in Fire and assimilation and as others previously discussed in this Tumblr thread: Nirvana in Fire, post-Episode 43 feels from thatbuildingisalsoastarbucks [Tumblr] & responses from
gixininja [Tumblr].
Anyway, just something for me to continue thinking about when consuming Chinese media (e.g. dramas and webnovels) :)